phydia63
replied to your post “While reading the part of that last post and the part about Casca…”

It can get really messy if Casca not getting her memories back leads to her leaving Guts because she remembers him assaulting her and go to Griffith because she doesn’t remembers his. That would be poor taste though, I’d much rather like Casca working through her feelings and memories.

Like if she only gets partial memories back, but doesn’t remember the eclipse? I actually hadn’t thought of that possibility, but yeaaaaah I def would not want that to happen. As well as being bad taste I think it would be cheap frustrating drama, and Casca would still be a plot device for conflict.

I’d also way prefer if she gets all her memories back and has to work through the trauma in some way, whether that means Elfhelm therapy or going on a rampage, I just want Casca to be an active character with agency again.